Risks & Rewards of High-Frequency Trading: Is High-Frequency Trading Worth It?

High frequency trading (HFT) is a complex, technology based trading strategy which sees the execution of large scale trades at very high speeds often within seconds to fractions of a second to take advantage of small price variations in financial markets. HFT uses very advanced algorithms and powerful computers to study market data, identify trading opportunities and execute orders at a speed which out performs any human trader. This approach is put forth to produce profit from very quick, small trades which are then scaled up over very large numbers of transactions. Although HFT presents great reward it also brings with it large scale issues which affect traders, institutions and the markets as a whole.

Understanding High-Frequency Trading: Tech Speed

High frequency trading is at the crossroads of top technology and very fast decision making. We see in it the use of complex algorithms which scan many markets and exchanges at once for arbitrage opportunities, pricing differences, or temporary market inefficiencies. The algorithms which run these trades are very quick which may be in the milli or micro second range, and may include tens of thousands or even millions of separate transactions in a single day.

Speed is at the core of High Frequency Trading. What we see is that even the smallest of delays in trade execution can mean missing out on profit as prices are ever fluctuating. Also, traders in HFT use best in class computer hardware, co location services (which is putting servers as close as possible to the exchange) and they fine tune their networks to reduce latency the delay between when an order is put in and when it is executed. HFT is known for its large scale of trades and very short term investment which is what which sets it apart from more traditional, longer term investment strategies.

Rewards of High-Frequency Trading: Liquidity and Financial Health

High frequency trading presents many appealing features which in turn makes it a very attractive option for institutions such as hedge funds, investment banks and proprietary trading firms.

1. Profit from Small Price Fluctuations: By way of speed and scale HFT takes advantage of very small price differences which for conventional strategies may not even be noticed. Very thin profits add up to large sums when run through the millions of trades HFT performs.
2. Increased Market Liquidity: HFT players serve as liquidity providers which means they are constantly in the market buying and selling securities. This action tends to reduce bid ask spreads which is the difference between what buyers pay and what sellers ask for in turn this improves price efficiency and market quality.
3. Arbitrage Opportunities: HFT strategies detect and take advantage of arbitrage opportunities like price differences of the same asset which trade between various exchanges, we see them profit before the price equalizes.
4. Competition & Market Efficiency: In the competitive environment of HFT we see a drive for faster execution and innovation in algorithms which in turn pushes markets to greater transparency and efficiency.
5. Automation Reduces Human Error: Through the use of computer generated decisions which remove emotional and psychological biases we see at times improved results.

These rewards which in turn make High Frequency Trading a very powerful tool when put to good use which in fact is to generate high returns via complex automated trading systems.

The Risks of High-Frequency Trading: Complexity and Market Effect

Although high frequency trading has its benefits it also presents issues which has brought criticism from regulators, market players, and academic experts.

1. Technological Failures and Errors: In that which is very technical in nature any issues, defects or system outages may see large scale results in a short time frame. Also we see that algorithms may fail which in turn may produce unexpected market orders or large scale trading.
2. Market Volatility and Flash Crashes: HFT’s speed and scale may cause market volatility. In the case of the not so rare “Flash Crash” of May 6, 2010 we saw very quick price drops which in part were a result of HFT which in turn amplified the sell off before the market recovered.
3. Predatory Practices and Fairness Concerns: Critics note that HFT groups get an edge over retail and small players from the speed at which they trade. Also we see in practice that large orders are broken up and constantly re-entered into the market which in turn distorts price perception.
4. Ghost Liquidity: Although HFT adds to the liquidity we see some of that which is “ghost liquidity” that dries up before other traders can react to it. This transient liquidity may mislead participants and reduce market robustness.
5. Regulatory and Legal Risks: HFT strategies’ complexity and opacity draw regulatory attention which in turn see companies bear compliance costs and at times take them to court when they are found to run against the market.
6. High Barriers to Entry: The issue of technology, infrastructure and expertise which is present in the success of HFT is also very high which in turn is mainly an advantage for large institutions and at the same time a barrier for market diversity.

Is High-Frequency Trading Worth the Risk?

Determin in what ways HFT is worth the risk is a issue of perspective, objective and resources. Large institutional players which are equipped with capital, technology infrastructure, and advanced quant skills see in HFT’s a great profit opportunity and a chance to gain a competitive edge. They use it to jump on short term opportunities and to put more liquidity into the markets.

For small investors and firms which don’t have access to those resources HFT is out of question and they also bear the risk of large scale system impact which they do not have any control over. We see in this the very complex, fast, and large scale nature of HFT which may cause large issues with little warning.

From the larger market point of view HFT increases liquidity and efficiency which in turn also brings about volatility spikes and fair play issues which in turn is a matter of great debate among regulators, economists and practitioners. Effective regulation, transparency and risk management is key to that fine balance between what HFT brings to the table and what it may put out.

Future of High-Frequency Trading: Innovation in a Regulated Environment

As technology in finance improves we see HFT strategies grow in complexity which in turn see the introduction of artificial intelligence and machine learning to that mix for the purpose of better decision speed and accuracy. Also to that we are seeing growth in regulation from the markets themselves which is in response to mitigate risk which includes the use of speed breaks, circuit breakers, and greater transparency of algorithms.

Institutions in the HFT space must be constantly at it with system improvements, risk management and compliance to sustain profitability and we see that the issue of what role and what impact HFT plays in today’s markets is very much alive.

High frequency trading reports great speed and has very advanced technology which in turn reports large profits and liquidity in financial markets. But also it’s a complex field which has the chance of disrupting the market and also brings up ethical issues which in turn mean that the risks are high. For the large and experienced institutions the rewards do in fact justify the investment and risk which is a part of the game. For the rest, caution and a full risk assessment is a must before jumping into this very fast moving environment.

There are some supportive reference article:

• Investopedia overview on HFT with pros and cons, including liquidity and ghost liquidity insights (Investopedia)
• Investopedia on systemic risk and flash crash amplification by HFT algorithms (Investopedia)
• CFI summary of HFT advantages (profit from tiny spreads, arbitrage, liquidity) and risks (ghost liquidity, market volatility, manipulation) (Corporate Finance Institute)
• In-depth pros & cons list including phantom liquidity, manipulation tactics like spoofing and quote stuffing (Walletinvestor.com)

Get more financial knowledge: TradingViews